Jury Foreman gives Details from Inside Sean Phillips' Trial - Northern Michigan's News Leader

Jury Foreman gives Details from Inside Sean Phillips' Trial

Posted: Updated:

There are so many questions as to what led to the jury's guilty verdict in the Sean Phillips' trial.  Searching for answers 9&10's Ann Marie LaFlamme sat down with the jury foreman, Jacob Lokers, and learned shocking inside details.

There was so much information and speculation throughout the trial, many wondered how the jury could hand down a verdict in less than six hours.  Lokers tells us it was very specific evidence that led to their unanimous verdict.

Lokers says five key pieces of evidence convinced them beyond a reasonable doubt that Phillips was guilty of unlawful imprisonment.   Those were the car seat and baby bag found in Phillips' car, Ariel Courtland's missing phone, Kate's clothes in Phillips' pocket and the note found in his jail clothes.

Loker says the biggest game changer was when the jury submitted a question to the judge during deliberation regarding Ariel Courtland, Kate's mom.   If Courtland knew what happened to Kate, could they still find Phillips guilty?

The answer from the judge was 'yes.'  Unlawful imprisonment is hiding Kate from the people of the State of Michigan.  At that point Lokers says they threw out almost all of Courtland's testimony, likely changing the verdict.

9&10's Ann Marie LaFlamme and photojournalist Tony Zyber have more inside information from the jury.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Two Accused of Adult Abuse, Sex Crimes in Chippewa County

    Two Accused of Adult Abuse, Sex Crimes in Chippewa County

    Thursday, August 21 2014 11:11 AM EDT2014-08-21 15:11:42 GMT
    A Drummond Island man and woman are in jail for sexually assaulting a vulnerable victim. Chippewa County Sheriff's Office says James Shaul and Melissa Ann Greiser were arrested Monday. 
    A Drummond Island man and woman are in jail for sexually assaulting a vulnerable victim. Chippewa County Sheriff's Office says James Shaul and Melissa Ann Greiser were arrested Monday. 
  • Woman Accused of Welfare Fraud in Wexford County

    Woman Accused of Welfare Fraud in Wexford County

    Wednesday, August 20 2014 5:44 PM EDT2014-08-20 21:44:49 GMT
    A Manton woman is accused of more than $96,000 in welfare fraud.
    A Manton woman is accused of more than $96,000 in welfare fraud.

  • Clare County Man Accused of Sex Crimes

    Clare County Man Accused of Sex Crimes

    Thursday, August 21 2014 9:23 AM EDT2014-08-21 13:23:03 GMT
    A Clare County man has been charged with sex crimes involving a child. Dale Thrush, of Farwell, faces several charges including first degree and second degree criminal sexual conduct...
    A Clare County man has been charged with sex crimes involving a child. Dale Thrush, of Farwell, faces several charges including first degree and second degree criminal sexual conduct...